What is intended by "surplus" (al-ʿafw) in this āyah? And was this command abrogated?
Jibu
Imām Ibn al-Jawzī (d. 597/1201) summarized the scholars' opinions in his book "Zād al-Masīr" as follows:
On the topic of abrogation, Ibn al-Jawzī comments: "Al-Suddī reports from his teachers that it was abrogated by the verse of zakāt, while others deny its abrogation. The decisive answer in this matter is that if we say that this verse imposed upon them the obligation of giving charity from surplus wealth, or that it required a form of charity before the institution of zakāt, then the verse is abrogated by the verse of zakāt. However, if we say it refers to the obligatory zakāt, as Mujāhid stated, or to voluntary charity, then it remains in effect."
What is the context of revelation for this āyah?
What is the etymology of the word khamr?
What is the "sin" (ithm) that is present in alcohol (khamr)?
What is the "sin" (ithm) that is present in gambling (maysir)?
What is meant by saying "their sin is greater than their benefit"?
What was the basis on which alcohol (khamr) was initially permitted?
Did this verse have an impact on the prohibition of alcohol (khamr) in Islam? And what about the prohibition of gambling?