How do scholars understand this āyah, and has it been abrogated?
Jibu
Imām Ibn al-Jawzī (d. 597/1201) summarized the scholars' opinions in his book "Zād al-Masīr" as follows:
1a. Some say "those who fight you" is abrogated. They argue that this implies fighting is permitted only against those among the disbelievers who are in a state of war, and this is abrogated by the following āyah. 1b. The second opinion is that "but do not transgress" is abrogated. According to this view, there are two interpretations of this "transgression": (1) The first is that it refers to killing those who do not fight. (2) The second is that it refers to initiating combat against the polytheists, which is abrogated by "the verse of the sword". (Ed: a reference to 9:5 or others.)
What does "trangress" refer to in this āyah?
Which āyah first gave permission to fight?